Ice Cream Girl is a younger student who appears in the end of episode "The Kid Came Back." after the Recess Gang finally got rid of Peanut Butter Kid (actually, they tried to apologize to him for being mean to him after they still had bad luck anyway, and he found some other kids to hang with). They then go back to their old ways, until they met her. Spinelli points out that she reminds her of the Peanut Butter Kid. They then run for their lives before she can become attached thinking she might bring bad luck like they had thought Peanut Butter Kid did.
She is a little girl who seem to be the same age as Peanut Butter Kid with black hair with 2 pigtails, wearing a light blue shirt with a elephant on it, with a skirt blue skirt and a yellow sweater tied to her wrist and seem to be barefooted with mud on her feet. She also seen eating a strawberry and vanilla ice cream with the strawberry on her face.